Should I redesign my website or start over?
It depends on the foundation, not the paint. If the site is fast, ranks for something, and just looks dated, a redesign can work. If it is slow, invisible in search, or built on a platform that fights every change, a rebuild costs less than dragging the old problems forward.
By the Lumen Local team. Updated August 2026.
Run the structural test. Does it load fast on a phone. Does it rank for anything. Can pages be added easily. Three yeses point to redesign. Two or more nos point to rebuild.
The trap is the cosmetic redesign of a broken foundation. New skin on a slow, unrankable site buys a year of looking better while still losing customers. The money moves nothing that matters.
Either way, keep what works. Pages that rank keep their addresses or get proper redirects. A rebuild done right keeps every bit of search value the old site earned.
Not sure where your business stands on these today? Our free market analysis measures exactly this and shows you the gaps in about a minute.
Where to go next
See the full set of answers, learn what we build, get the full trade playbooks, read the pricing guide, or just get your free market analysis.
See where your local marketing really stands.
Get your free market analysis. We look at where you stand, then build the system that fixes it, and you pay only once it books you a job.
Nothing upfront. Pay $3,000/mo only once it books you a job. One company per metro.